2018 Guide: Best Fish Finder for the Money

Shopping for a new fish finder can be a daunting task, especially for the experienced angler. There really is no one “best fish finder”, and there never will be. There are dozens of models manufactured each year, and each has it’s own place for best use.

The purpose of this guide is to help you cut through the confusion and the marketing buzzwords to help you choose the best fish finder for the money that fits your style of fishing.  We’ll walk you through the different types of sonar and features found on today’s top fishing electronics, and they can be used to help you enjoy your time on the water and catch more fish.

1. Choose by Price Range

Do you have a specific budget in mind for your next marine electronics purchase? We’ve got you covered with guides for choosing the best fish finder in several price ranges.

2. Latest Fish Finder Reviews

2018 looks to be another great year for marine electronics. There are a ton of products to review, and we’ll list them here.

  • Garmin ECHOMAP Plus – The whole series has been refreshed, with side and down imaging sonars, plus some new touchscreens.
  • Garmin STRIKER Plus – This popular series has added a 9 inch SideVu model.
  • Lowrance Elite Ti – New 9 Ti and 12 Ti Totalscan touchscreen fish finders for 2018.
  • Lowrance HDS Carbon – The Carbon series is replacing the HDS Gen3, and now has a massive 16 inch unit.
  • Lowrance Hook2 – A welcome refresh of the Hook series, with all new displays, SplitShot and TripleShot configurations, and some very interesting prices.
  • Humminbird HELIX MEGA SI G2N – Mega Imaging was HUGE last year, and so far only HUmminbird has this technology. The clearest, most detailed images around come off MEGA imaging units.
  • Humminbird HELIX MEGA DI G2N – An expansion of the MEGA lineup, with MEGA Down Imaging only models.
  • Humminbird SOLIX – From the ashes of the ONIX rises the SOLIX series, all new and improved in every aspect. SOLIX has been very popular thanks to MEGA and now comes in a more affordable SOLIX 10 option.
  • Raymarine Axiom – Raymarine is making a new push into consumer fish finders with the Axiom. They look fantastic, with their own 3D imaging technology.

3. Top Fish Finders by Type of Sonar

Every few years there seems to be some type of new sonar technology that pushes the envelope for consumer grade fishing electronics.  For many years, flashers were the deal, like Lowrance’s famous “Green Box” locator, and Humminbird’s equally renowned “Super 60” flasher. From there, fish finders turned to paper “graphs”, and then LCD displays that revealed more information about what was below the boat.

Then in the mid 2000’s, Humminbird was the first company to release affordable side imaging to the consumer, and it was a smash success.  From that point on there has been an arms race that some have come to call the “Sonar Wars“.  The guide below will help you understand each of these fish finding technologies and help you decide if you need them.

Kayak Fish Finders

Kayak fishing has exploded in popularity in the last five years. If you are looking to get into kayak fishing, now is a great time. There has never been so many awesome fishing kayak options and quality fish finders to put on them. There are several really good 5 and 7 inch models that have awesome screens and are easy on your budget.  See all our Kayak Fish Finder Reviews, or check out our Top 3 recommended Kayak Fish Finders.

Model:
Garmin Echomap Plus 73SV with CV52HW-TM transducer, 010-01897-01
Garmin Striker Plus 7SV with CV52HW-TM transducer, 010-01874-00
Humminbird 410340-1 Helix 7 CHIRP Si GPS G2N                   
Lowrance 000-14289-001 HOOK2-7 Combo, Inland Maps, DownScan
Raymarine Dragonfly-5 Pro Sonar/GPS with US C-Map Essentials
Display:
7.0″ (800×480)
7.0″ (800×480)
7.0″ (800×480)
7.0″ (800×480)
5" (800x480)
Sonar:
CHIRP 2D/CV/SV
CHIRP 2D/CV/SV
CHIRP 2D/SI/DI
CHIRP 2D/DownScan
CHIRP 2D/DI
Live Mapping:
Model:
Garmin Echomap Plus 73SV with CV52HW-TM transducer, 010-01897-01
Display:
7.0″ (800×480)
Sonar:
CHIRP 2D/CV/SV
Live Mapping:
View on:
Model:
Garmin Striker Plus 7SV with CV52HW-TM transducer, 010-01874-00
Display:
7.0″ (800×480)
Sonar:
CHIRP 2D/CV/SV
Live Mapping:
View on:
Model:
Humminbird 410340-1 Helix 7 CHIRP Si GPS G2N                   
Display:
7.0″ (800×480)
Sonar:
CHIRP 2D/SI/DI
Live Mapping:
View on:
Model:
Lowrance 000-14289-001 HOOK2-7 Combo, Inland Maps, DownScan
Display:
7.0″ (800×480)
Sonar:
CHIRP 2D/DownScan
Live Mapping:
View on:
Model:
Raymarine Dragonfly-5 Pro Sonar/GPS with US C-Map Essentials
Display:
5" (800x480)
Sonar:
CHIRP 2D/DI
Live Mapping:
View on:

*Last updated 2018-07-21 at 20:04 / Product info from Amazon Product Advertising API


Portable Fish Finders

Portable fish finders are units that are easily attached to and removed from a boat. A portable unit can be useful if you take infrequent trips to the lake, rent boats, or have a smaller fishing boat that isn’t conducive to a permanently mounted fish finder. These units typically come with a separate battery that you stow in the carrying case

Guide: Top Portable Fish Finders

There are also castable fish finders, which are basically a transducer pod that floats, and a smartphone app is the fish finder. These kinds of fish finders are excellent for fishing from shore or from small watercraft.

Model:
Garmin Striker 4 with Portable Kit
Humminbird 5 410260-1 Fish finder
Humminbird 410170-1 PIRANHAMAX 4.3 PT Fish finder with Dual Frequency Portable Sonar
Garmin STRIKER 4 Portable
HELIX 5 CHIRP GPS G2 PT
Humminbird PiranhaMAX 4 PT
Size
3.5" (480x320)
5" (800x480)
4.3″ (480×272)
View on:
Model:
Garmin Striker 4 with Portable Kit
Garmin STRIKER 4 Portable
Size
3.5" (480x320)
View on:
Model:
Humminbird 5 410260-1 Fish finder
HELIX 5 CHIRP GPS G2 PT
Size
5" (800x480)
View on:
Model:
Humminbird 410170-1 PIRANHAMAX 4.3 PT Fish finder with Dual Frequency Portable Sonar
Humminbird PiranhaMAX 4 PT
Size
4.3″ (480×272)
View on:

*Last updated 2018-07-21 at 20:04 / Product info from Amazon Product Advertising API


Fish Finders for Ice Fishing

Ice fishing requires a special type of unit to be effective in catching fish under the ice. You are working your bait vertically so you want to be able to see fish under your bait, as well as see your bait as it drops down the water column.

The first thing to look for is a good flasher display. Mechanical flashers tend to breakdown more frequently and require repairs, so for that reason we suggest getting a digital flasher.

Most 5 inch portable units now have a flasher option in the available views. You can also do a split screen to see traditional 2D sonar. With these two views you can see fish and your bait under hole in the ice.


Down Imaging Sonar

Down Imaging DiagramDown imaging uses a transducer that emits a single extremely thin slice of high frequency sound waves to create a lifelike 3D appearance of whats below your boat. When stacked up and painted on your fish finder, these thin slices of sonar returns make it much clearer as to what is below the boat. What might look like a blob of “something” in standard sonar, is instantly revealed to be brush, rocks, fish, or other kinds of structure.

Each manufacturer has their own version of down imaging sonar; Humminbird’s Down Imaging, Lowrance’s DownScan, Garmin’s DownVü, and Raymarine’s Dragonfly. The imaging looks very similar on all the brands, so it’s really up to you to look closely at screenshots and specifications and decide what will work best for you. With imaging being more or less equal, look for the best and largest screen, as well as for the mapping capabilities that will meet your fishing style.

Down Imaging Fish Finder Reviews

Model:
Editor's Choice
Johnson Outdoors Hummingbird 410510-1 Helix 10 Chirp Mega DI GPS G2N fishing-charts-and-maps, Black
Touchscreen
Garmin Echomap Plus 73Cv with CV22HW-TM transducer, 010-01893-01
Lowrance 000-14289-001 HOOK2-7 Combo, Inland Maps, DownScan
Garmin Striker Plus 7Cv with Cv20-TM transducer, 010-01873-00
Humminbird HELIX 7 Chirp DI GPS G2N Fishfinder 410330-1
Display:
10.1" (1024x600)
7" (800x480)
7.0″ (800×480)
7.0″ (800×480)
7.0″ (800×480)
DI Frequencies:
455/800/1200 kHz
455/800kHz
455/800 kHz
455/800 kHz
455/800 kHz
MEGA DI
Live Mapping
Editor's Choice
Model:
Johnson Outdoors Hummingbird 410510-1 Helix 10 Chirp Mega DI GPS G2N fishing-charts-and-maps, Black
Display:
10.1" (1024x600)
DI Frequencies:
455/800/1200 kHz
MEGA DI
Live Mapping
View on:
Touchscreen
Model:
Garmin Echomap Plus 73Cv with CV22HW-TM transducer, 010-01893-01
Display:
7" (800x480)
DI Frequencies:
455/800kHz
MEGA DI
Live Mapping
View on:
Model:
Lowrance 000-14289-001 HOOK2-7 Combo, Inland Maps, DownScan
Display:
7.0″ (800×480)
DI Frequencies:
455/800 kHz
MEGA DI
Live Mapping
View on:
Model:
Garmin Striker Plus 7Cv with Cv20-TM transducer, 010-01873-00
Display:
7.0″ (800×480)
DI Frequencies:
455/800 kHz
MEGA DI
Live Mapping
View on:
Model:
Humminbird HELIX 7 Chirp DI GPS G2N Fishfinder 410330-1
Display:
7.0″ (800×480)
DI Frequencies:
455/800 kHz
MEGA DI
Live Mapping
View on:

*Last updated 2018-07-21 at 20:04 / Product info from Amazon Product Advertising API


Side Imaging Sonar

Side Imaging DiagramWhere down imaging uses one sonar beam looking directly towards bottom, side imaging uses two beams that are angled slightly upward in both side directions.  The two beams together create photograph-like images of the lake bottom on both sides of your boat, revealing contour changes, bottom composition transitions, fish, and structure all at the same time.

Side imaging is an extremely useful tool for searching out fish holding structure on the lake.  It can significantly reduce the time it takes to find fish, making you more efficient, allowing you to spend more time trying to catch them.

Side Imaging Tutorial, Tips and Tricks

Side Imaging Fish Finder Reviews

MEGA Side Imaging: If you are looking for the best possible images in a fish finder, there is nothing better than the Humminbird MEGA units. They utilize 1200 KHz frequency (1.2 MHz) to get ultra clear images both side and down looking sonar. MEGA is only available in the HELIX 9, 10, and 12, as well as the SOLIX SI models.

Best Side Imaging Fish Finders

Model:
Editor's Choice
Humminbird 410120-1 Helix 10 CHIRP Mega Si GPS G2N Fishing Charts & Maps
Garmin Echomap Plus 93SV with CV52HW-TM transducer, 010-01901-01
Highest Resolution
Humminbird 410490-1 Solix 10 Chirp
Elite Navico Ti 9" Sonar/GPS Total Scan Bundle
Best Budget SI
Garmin Striker Plus 9SV with CV52HW-TM transducer, 010-01875-00
Display:
10" (1024x600)
9" (800x480)
10" (1280x800)
9" (800x480)
9" (800x480)
SI/DI Frequencies:
455/800/1200 kHz
455/800 kHz
455/800/1200 kHz
455/800 kHz
455/800 kHz
MEGA Imaging:
Live Mapping:
Editor's Choice
Model:
Humminbird 410120-1 Helix 10 CHIRP Mega Si GPS G2N Fishing Charts & Maps
Display:
10" (1024x600)
SI/DI Frequencies:
455/800/1200 kHz
MEGA Imaging:
Live Mapping:
View on
Model:
Garmin Echomap Plus 93SV with CV52HW-TM transducer, 010-01901-01
Display:
9" (800x480)
SI/DI Frequencies:
455/800 kHz
MEGA Imaging:
Live Mapping:
View on
Highest Resolution
Model:
Humminbird 410490-1 Solix 10 Chirp
Display:
10" (1280x800)
SI/DI Frequencies:
455/800/1200 kHz
MEGA Imaging:
Live Mapping:
View on
Model:
Elite Navico Ti 9" Sonar/GPS Total Scan Bundle
Display:
9" (800x480)
SI/DI Frequencies:
455/800 kHz
MEGA Imaging:
Live Mapping:
View on
Best Budget SI
Model:
Garmin Striker Plus 9SV with CV52HW-TM transducer, 010-01875-00
Display:
9" (800x480)
SI/DI Frequencies:
455/800 kHz
MEGA Imaging:
Live Mapping:
View on

*Last updated 2018-07-21 at 20:04 / Product info from Amazon Product Advertising API


360 Imaging & Scanning Sonar

As great as they are, down and side imaging have a few drawbacks.  First, you need to be moving forward to be able to get a clear picture.  Idling speed is best, but you can slow the scrolling speed down to show a good picture while fishing from the trolling motor.  The second drawback, is that you can only see what you have already passed over with your boat.  It’s great to see the structure, but it doesn’t do you much good if you’ve already passed it.

Humminbird came out with an innovative solution to this problem, called 360 Imaging.  360 Imaging uses a rotating transducer to sweep in a full circle around you and the boat.  This allows you to see in front of you, behind you, and to all sides without moving at all.  The rotating transducer refreshes the screen even while you are stationary, allowing you to see targets in front of you to cast to.  Now you can clearly see casting targets such as pockets and turns in the weed-line, as well as brush, stumps, and trees.

360 Imaging Screenshot
360 Imaging Screenshot Annotations

The 360 Imaging transducers are a fairly expensive add on, but we truly believe it can be a huge leap forward forward for serious anglers, especially bass and panfish anglers.  Most of Humminbird’s higher end units are capable of displaying 360 Imaging data, as long as you have the most recent software updates.  We have used and recommend the bow mounted 360 unit, which you can see the review here.


CHIRP Fish Finders

CHIRP sonar is one of the newest technologies to come to fish finders that the average Joe can afford.  Lowrance and Garmin and helped push this type of sonar into the mainstream, and now Humminbird and the others are starting to follow.  You are probably wonder what exactly is CHIRP, how does it work, and what are the benefits?  You aren’t the only one, so here is a short primer.

Where regular sonar uses a fixed frequency, such as 83 kHz or 200 kHz, CHIRP transducers transmit longer sweeps across a range of frequencies.  CHIRP transducers are essentially putting many times more sound energy into the water column than a traditional transducer, making it much easier to detect objects in the water column.  This also means objects in the water can be viewed with better clarity, with better target separation, and at greater maximum depths.

CHIRP has been normally been relegated to saltwater fishing boats, where they need the greater depth capabilities, but the fish finder manufacturers are finding ways to afford ably process the CHIRP signals in a way that benefits the typical freshwater fisherman in shallower water.  For some of the best units with CHIRP, check out the below article, as well as the excellent primer video from Lowrance.


 

Best Fish Finder GPS Combos

2D Sonar DiagramRegular 2D sonar uses a cone shaped sound wave to ping the water column directly below the boat.  The higher the frequency, the narrower the cone.  In general, the narrower the beam, the higher definition you will see on the screen.  The lower frequency beam with wider cone angle will give you more coverage area, which can be helpful when searching for fish.

When your boat passes over a large fish, or the fish passes through part of your sonar cone, it can appear as an arch. It takes a very specific circumstance to display an arch on a fish finder, so do not be alarmed if you do not immediately or always see the arches.  Sometimes the fish look like thin lines, ovals, or balls, it just depends on the speed of your boat, and where the fish are in the cone.

When you see a fish finder advertised as “dual beam”, this just means it has the ability to use both beams at the same time.  You can usually view them side by side, blended together, or on separate screens in order to help you understand whats happening below your boat.

All of the top fish finders today will be GPS combo units.  These units have 1 or 2 SD or Micro SD card slots for using mapping cards such as Navionics or Lakemaster.  Lakemaster map cards are exclusive for use in Humminbird fish finders, while Navionics can be used in almost any brand.

In the past few years there have been exciting advances in mapping technology coming out, such as DIY mapping software like AutoChart, AutoChart Live, Navionics SonarCharts, and Insight Genesis.  Some cards like Lakemaster PLUS and Navionics Platinum+ are also offering Satelite Overlay as a way to enhance you lake maps.


Comments 52

  1. jeff howard
  2. Mike Wells
      • Dave
  3. kingFisher
    • Tom
  4. Jim
  5. Jim
  6. Lkea
  7. Liam Coyle
  8. Marcus odoli
  9. John
  10. Loonytoon
  11. Chris
  12. Alex
      • Joe
  13. Chris
  14. Rob
  15. Oscar Trevino
  16. Luke
  17. Eric Carter
      • Eric Carter
  18. Aaron T
    • GregB
  19. Steve
  20. James W
  21. Alex
  22. Jeremy Ertz
  23. Greg

Leave a Reply